Fullmetal Alchemist Watch Order: The Complete Guide & the 2003 vs Brotherhood Confusion Decoded
📅 September 21, 2026 · ⏱ 10 min read · ⚗️ 2 Full Anime + 5 Films Covered
Start Reading 2003 or Brotherhood?Fullmetal Alchemist has one of the most genuinely split fandoms in anime, and it isn’t over a plot twist — it’s over which of two entirely separate anime adaptations you should watch, since they eventually tell different stories with different endings from the same starting point.
This guide sorts out the whole franchise. You get a clean recommended order, a full decoder explaining exactly why the 2003 series and Brotherhood diverge, coverage of both movies and every OVA, and an honest verdict on the live-action trilogy most guides tell you to skip.
For most first-time viewers: watch Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood (all 64 episodes) — it’s the complete, faithful adaptation of the manga. Watch the original 2003 series (51 episodes) → Conqueror of Shamballa afterward as a separate, darker “what if” experience, not a prerequisite. See the decoder below before picking a starting point.
The Recommended Watch Order (Full)
Because the two anime versions are alternate takes rather than sequential chapters, this order treats Brotherhood as the main path and the 2003 series as a separate, optional continuity — not something you need to sit through first.
Brothers Edward and Alphonse Elric search for the Philosopher’s Stone to restore their bodies after a forbidden alchemy ritual goes catastrophically wrong. A complete, faithful adaptation of Hiromu Arakawa’s manga from start to finish, and consistently ranked among the best-reviewed anime ever made. Most guides recommend starting here, or watching this exclusively.
A standalone adventure set sometime during the Brotherhood timeline, introducing new characters and a self-contained conflict. Fan guides disagree on its exact episode placement, but since it doesn’t affect the main plot, watching it anytime after finishing Brotherhood works fine.
The original TV anime, following the manga closely for its first 25 or so episodes before diverging into an entirely original story, cast of villains, and mythology. Darker and more melancholy in tone than Brotherhood — worth exploring on its own terms once you know the real ending elsewhere.
Picks up two years after the 2003 series’ finale, following Edward in an alternate Weimar Germany. This film only makes sense as a continuation of the 2003 continuity — skip it entirely if you only watched Brotherhood.
The 2003 era includes shorts like Chibi Party and Reflections; Brotherhood includes four short OVAs — The Blind Alchemist, Simple People, The Tale of the Master, and Yet Another Man’s Battlefield — that expand on character backstories. All are fun bonus content, none are required.
2003 vs Brotherhood — Decoded
This is the single most-asked question in the Fullmetal Alchemist fandom, and the honest answer requires understanding a production timing accident rather than a creative choice.
| Question | Fullmetal Alchemist (2003) | Brotherhood |
|---|---|---|
| Follows the manga’s actual story? | Only for roughly the first half | ✅ Yes, throughout |
| Ending matches the manga? | ❌ No — entirely original | ✅ Yes |
| Tone | Darker, more melancholy, psychologically heavy | Faster-paced, more consistent, ultimately more hopeful |
| Widely considered “the” version to watch? | By longtime fans and completionists | ✅ Yes, by most newcomers and critics |
The Live-Action Trilogy
Between 2017 and 2022, Fullmetal Alchemist got a full live-action trilogy from director Fumihiko Sori. Here’s an honest look at whether it’s worth your time.
Fullmetal Alchemist (2017)
The first live-action film, adapting the story’s early chapters. Widely criticized for rushed pacing and weaker character work compared to either anime.
The Revenge of Scar (2022)
The first of two back-to-back Netflix sequels, released for the franchise’s 20th anniversary, with most of the original cast returning. Generally considered an improvement over the first film.
The Final Transmutation (2022)
The trilogy’s conclusion, released a month after The Revenge of Scar, depicting the story’s final battle. The longest of the three live-action films.
What This Means for You
Most guides, including this one, recommend skipping all three. They cover ground both anime and the manga already handle better, and don’t add anything essential to the story.
Quick Reference Table: Every Entry in the Franchise
| Title | Type | Year | Essential? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood | TV Series (64 eps) | 2009–2010 | Definitive Version |
| The Sacred Star of Milos | Film | 2011 | Optional Side Story |
| Fullmetal Alchemist (2003) | TV Series (51 eps) | 2003–2004 | Alternate Take |
| The Conqueror of Shamballa | Film | 2005 | Only If You Watched 2003 |
| Brotherhood OVAs (4 shorts) | OVA | 2009–2010 | Optional |
| 2003-Era OVAs & Shorts | OVA | 2004–2005 | Optional |
| Fullmetal Alchemist (2017) | Live-Action Film | 2017 | Skippable |
| The Revenge of Scar | Live-Action Film | 2022 | Skippable |
| The Final Transmutation | Live-Action Film | 2022 | Skippable |
Frequently Asked Questions
Final Verdict: What’s the Best Way to Watch Fullmetal Alchemist?
For most viewers: start with Brotherhood. It’s the version that actually finishes Hiromu Arakawa’s story, and it’s the one most consistently recommended as one of the best anime ever made. If you only ever watch one Fullmetal Alchemist series, make it this one.
The 2003 series is worth exploring afterward on its own terms — not as a prerequisite, not as a lesser draft, but as a genuinely different, darker interpretation of the same starting premise. Going in expecting it to match Brotherhood’s plot past the first 25 episodes is exactly the mix-up that causes most of the confusion around this franchise.
Skip the live-action trilogy unless you’re a completionist, and treat the OVAs and side films as bonus content to enjoy whenever curiosity strikes rather than required viewing before you can call the story finished.
Ready to Start Watching?
Bookmark this page for the full order whenever you’re ready to dive in. And if this guide helped, check out our other watch order guides below.
View All Watch Order GuidesShare on other Social Media Platforms